Job offer comparison template for project and program managers
Put two offers and your current job side by side, one item per row, with what is in writing and what still needs a question. Download the blank grid, see a filled row, and check your reply to the recruiter before you send it. Not financial or legal advice.
Free offer comparison template in Word and CSV
Free, no sign-up, nothing to install. The Word file has one table per group; the CSV file has one row per line, with the group in the first column, so you can sort and filter it.
What the grid is for
An offer arrives in pieces: a number on a call, a benefits summary as a PDF, a remark about remote days in an email, a level that only shows up in the letter. Two offers at once double the pieces. The grid puts every item on its own row so you compare like with like, and so the gaps show up before you answer.
The money rows are empty fields, not targets. You copy each figure and term exactly as the employer wrote it. The other rows carry what decides most PM moves as much as pay does: the level, the scope you would own, the manager, the sponsor, the remote days and the next step up. Two columns keep you honest: whether the item is in writing, and how much it matters to you.
How to fill it in, step by step
- Ask each employer for the offer in writing, with the benefits summary, before you fill in a single row.
- Open the CSV file in a spreadsheet, delete the FICTIONAL example row, and rename Offer A and Offer B to the company names.
- Fill in the Current job or baseline column first. If you are not working now, write what you would accept and leave the rest empty.
- Copy each figure and term from the written offer as it stands. Where a term was only said on a call, write it in and mark In writing? as no.
- Score each row in Matters to me from 1 to 3 before you compare the offers, so the scores reflect you and not the larger number.
- Read across each row and write what is missing or unclear in Question to ask. Keep it to one question per row.
- Pick the two or three questions that matter most and ask them in one call or one email, then update the grid when the answers come back in writing.
A filled row (FICTIONAL)
One row from two made up offers for a senior program manager, on the item that is often left out of the letter. There is no pay figure in the example on purpose: those rows are yours to copy from your own offers.
| Field | Example (FICTIONAL) |
|---|---|
| Item | Remote and office days |
| Current job or baseline | Fully remote (FICTIONAL) |
| Offer A | 3 days remote, 2 in the office (FICTIONAL) |
| Offer B | Fully remote, one team week on site each quarter (FICTIONAL) |
| In writing? | A: in the offer letter. B: only in a recruiter email |
| Matters to me (1 to 3) | 3 |
| Question to ask | Can the on site weeks of Offer B be written into the offer letter? |
FICTIONAL: the project, the people, the company and the numbers are made up to show the level of detail. The same row is the first row of both files; delete it before you start.
Reading the grid before you answer
Look first at the rows scored 3. If an offer leads on most of them, the rows scored 1 rarely change the answer. If the offers split, the Question to ask cells on the rows scored 3 are the conversation to have with the recruiter.
Then read the In writing? column. A row that matters to you and is not in writing is a risk, whatever the figure. Asking for it to be written into the letter is a normal request, and the answer tells you something about the employer too.
Check your reply before it goes to the recruiter
The Question to ask column turns into your reply. Write it the way you would send it and paste it into the free recruiter reply check: it marks lines you may not want to put in writing yet, such as your past pay or a promise to sign before you have read the letter. It does not suggest a figure.
Limits
- Not financial or legal advice: the template holds no figures to ask for and does not explain taxes, equity terms, benefits plans or contracts.
- It compares what you write down; it cannot tell you whether an offer is fair or what an employer will agree to change.
- Bonus and equity depend on terms the grid does not model. Copy the terms as written and ask the employer, or a qualified adviser, what they mean for you.
- An offer letter is usually confidential. Keep the file on your own device and leave names out if you share it.
Questions
How do I compare two job offers side by side?
Put each item of the offers on its own row: base, bonus, equity, benefits, remote days, level, scope, manager and growth. Copy the terms from the written offers, score how much each row matters to you, and note what is not in writing yet. The rows that matter most and differ most are the ones to ask about.
Does the template tell me how much to ask for?
No. The pay rows are empty fields for the figures in your own offer letters. For what PM job postings state, the salary ranges page shows public posted ranges, not offers. The template is not financial or legal advice.
Can I edit the template in Word or a spreadsheet?
Yes. The .docx file opens in Word and other word processors, and the .csv file opens in Excel, Google Sheets and other spreadsheet programs. Both are free, with no sign-up.